Talk on Islam and Comparative Theology “The People of The Book, ahl al-kitāb: A Modern Comparative Theological Exploration” by Richard Kimball (TCD)

This paper examines the use of the Qur’ānic term ahl al-kitāb by several contemporary Muslim and Christian scholars in the context of our increasingly interconnected and pluralist societies. The Arabic term ahl al-kitāb is frequently translated as the People of the Book. The People of the Book are the religious communities that the Qur’ān identifies as following divine revelation in the form of a book. Traditionally these communities are Jews, Christians, Sabians and to a lesser extent Zoroastrians. Sometimes the Qur’ān praises these communities and their sacred texts and other times they are criticised. Therefore, what the Qur’ān has to say about these communities and their texts is highly contextual, requiring nuanced understanding of any verse in question.

For Islamic scholars, the application of the Qur’ānic commentary tradition, known as tafsīr allows for an authoritative link to the past that anchors their contribution in modern discourse. Variations from past interpretations of particular social issues, due to modern social pressures like participation as equal citizens in multi-faith and multi-cultural societies, often follow formal reflection on past scholarship, combined with the introduction of new modern contexts as variables in the decision-making process. The research subsequently demonstrates the resilience of the parameters set within the traditional commentary for Muslim interlocutors. Therefore, this paper posits, greater awareness by Christians of the application of the traditional commentary, can play an important role in the development of improved dialogue and cooperation, whereby each may respect the other as fully Muslim and fully Christian.

Key words: ahl al-kitāb, asbâb an-nuzûl, bid‘ah, fitra, hadīth, People of the Book, ra’y, sahabah, tafsīr, tabi’un, taqlīd.